European Court Confirms Massive €4.1B Penalty for Google’s Android Practices
In a consequential ruling for the European digital market, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has upheld the European Commission’s decision to impose a record fine on Google. The court sided with the regulator’s view that Google exploited its dominant market position in mobile operating systems to disadvantage competitors.
Google must now pay a fine of 4.1 billion euros. Only yesterday, the US internet giant was fined 1.5 billion dollars in Sweden for disadvantaging Klarna subsidiary Pricerunner in price comparisons within its search engine.
The reasons for the ruling
The legal disputes stem from a 2018 decision by the European Commission. At that time, Google was accused of systematically restricting competition in mobile devices through three specific practices:
- Service Bundling: Google required Android device manufacturers to pre-install Google Search and the Chrome browser as a condition for gaining access to the Play Store.
- Exclusivity Payments: The company made payments to major hardware manufacturers and mobile network operators on the condition that Google Search was exclusively pre-installed as the default on their devices.
- Blocking Alternatives: By threatening to withdraw Google App permissions, Google prevented manufacturers from bringing devices to market that used alternative, so-called “forked” (modified) versions of Android.
While the court acknowledged that Google users are still able to download alternative browsers or search engines, the strategy of pre-installing standard applications was deemed an unlawful hindrance to competition.
Procedural history and amount of the fine
The original fine, imposed by the European Commission in 2018, amounted to 4.3 billion euros. Following a revision in 2022, the amount was corrected to the now-confirmed 4.1 billion euros. With the ECJ dismissing the appeal, this legal battle regarding this matter is concluded. This represents the highest fine ever imposed by the European Commission against Google.
Google’s reaction
Google has criticized the ruling. A spokesperson for the company stated that the court “failed to recognize the significant investments” Google has made to keep Android open, interoperable, and free. According to Google, the business model behind Android has expanded rather than restricted choices for users and developers.
At the same time, the company pointed out that it had already adjusted its contractual agreements in 2018 to comply with the European Commission’s original decision. Google emphasized that it remains focused on innovation and openness.
Context of EU regulations
The ruling is part of a series of measures by the European Union against the market power of major tech corporations. In recent years, Google has already faced high fines for favoring its own services in the shopping sector as well as in online advertising. The current ruling underscores the EU’s intensified efforts to enforce fair competition in the digital sector.

